South African Police Face £2.2M Settlement After Rubber Bullet Blinds Innocent Civilian
In a landmark ruling highlighting police accountability, South African authorities have been ordered to pay R2.2 million in damages to a young entrepreneur blinded by a rubber bullet. The case underscores growing concerns about police tactics and civilian rights during civil unrest.
A young woman who lost her eye to a police rubber bullet has been awarded substantial compensation by South African courts
Court Mandates Substantial Compensation for Police Violence Victim
The North West High Court in Mahikeng has delivered a significant ruling against South Africa's Police Ministry, ordering a compensation payment of R2.2 million (approximately £93,000) to a young woman who lost her eye due to police action during civil unrest.
Tragic Circumstances of Civilian Casualty
The incident, which occurred on 11 July 2019, saw a then 19-year-old entrepreneur struck by a rubber bullet while innocently conducting household chores in her private property. The victim, who had been running a promising small business selling homemade atchar, was earning roughly R3,600 monthly before the incident.
"The scarring beneath the right eye from the surgery adds to her disfigurement and deepens her emotional discomfort," the court's judgment stated, highlighting the profound physical and psychological impact of the incident.
Long-term Impact and Personal Trauma
The injury resulted in complete vision loss in her right eye, necessitating its surgical removal and replacement with a prosthetic. The court heard compelling testimony about the ongoing challenges faced by the victim, including:
- Psychological trauma from the prosthetic eye's unnatural appearance
- Social withdrawal and loss of confidence
- Physical complications including mucosal discharge
- Significant impact on her quality of life and future prospects
Comprehensive Settlement Details
Acting Judge Roshiela Titus's ruling acknowledged the extensive damages suffered by the plaintiff, with the final settlement of R2,205,567 encompassing:
- General damages for pain and suffering
- Compensation for loss of earnings
- Coverage for future medical expenses
- Provision for assistive devices
- Personal care assistance costs
Implications for Police Accountability
This ruling sets a significant precedent for police accountability in South Africa, particularly regarding the use of force during civil unrest. It raises important questions about law enforcement protocols and the protection of civilian rights during periods of social tension.
Thomas Reynolds
Correspondent for a London daily, specialist in British foreign policy and transatlantic issues.